Find My Team

Submit Photos
Log in to High School OT with one click using your favorite social network:
OR
Log in using your High School OT account:



Wrong email/password combination.

Forgot password?

Register with High School OT using your favorite social network:
OR
Register for a High School OT account using our web form.
Log In
Register
Daily Schedule:
May. 17

High School Sports

State rule prevents Sampson teen from suiting up for football

Aug 11, 2011

Community support is growing for a Sampson County teenager with Down syndrome whose passion to play football is being quashed by the state agency that regulates high school athletics.

For the past two years, Brett Bowden has suited up for every practice with Hobbton High School's varsity football team, and although he doesn't play in the games, he's always on the sideline cheering on his teammates.

His teammates even let him run a touchdown play after every game.

But Brett recently turned 19, and the North Carolina High School Athletic Association says he is no longer eligible to suit up because he is too old. Allowing him to do so, Hobbton High athletics administrators say, is a violation of state rules.

"When I found out, I was heartbroken. I mean, the tears were just flowing," Brett's mother, Pat Bowden, said Monday. "It means a lot for him just to stand there and be a part of them, just like them."

A spokesman for the NCHAA says it understands and appreciates the community support for Brett but that there's nothing that can be done. He can continue wearing a team jersey and sitting on the sideline, but he can't suit up or play.

Brett's family and friends have gone online in an effort to bring attention to the story.

Since starting a Facebook page last Friday, more than 1,200 people have rallied behind Brett, expressing their desires that he be allowed to continue suiting up.

"What they are doing to Brett is so unfair," one person wrote on the page. "The presence of Brett (on) the team teaches a big lesson to the community and teammates. LET HIM PLAY."

"The whole NCHSAA should be utterly ashamed of themselves for being so inconsiderate to someone that just wants to be a part of something!" another person wrote.

Pat Bowden says her son still doesn't know that he's no longer allowed to put on the uniform.

Family and friend are hoping that there is still a chance that the NCHSAA will make an exception before the team's first scrimmage this week.

If not, Pat Bowden says, she will have to explain to Brett why he can't wear his uniform.

Brett has a close relationship to the team, his mother says, and the news that he can no longer participate in practices has been difficult for them, too.

"They're his family," Pat Bowden said. "They're his brothers, his best friends."

"It literally breaks my heart," said Charles Chestnutt, Brett's teammate and close friend.

The Hobbton High football team is still reeling from the loss last year of its starting quarterback, Brad Evans, who committed suicide.

Brett has worn Evans' number on his helmet, and other players say that he has helped them heal.

"He's just been my buddy. He's been my inspiration – one of the reasons I keep doing what I do every day, playing football," Chestnutt said.

  • Reporter: Mike Charbonneau
  • Web Editor: Kelly Gardner
COMMENTS

65 Comments



page 1 | 2 | 3
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Someone mentioned that the parents have wanted their child to be mainstreamed and treated the same as all other children in regards to his educational experience. Well, now they have to accept a rule that has no doubt affected hundreds, if not thousands, of students who have aged out at 19. I believe the rule is a good one and should be enforced. Put a jersey (not a full uniform) on Brett and let him work as a manager for the team. If you want to be treated like everyone else, accept the decision and move on.
whistler411
August 9, 2011 5:07 p.m.
• Report abuse

Same thing in florida happened and the courts backed the state and there age requirements.

Jean Pellen, an attorney with the policy Enforcement Service in the Civil Rights Division (CRD) of the U.S. Department of Education, explained that "the state has the right to make reasonable regulations regarding safety and well being. The age regulation, as it pertains to athletics, is not a violation of a student's civil rights if implementation includes all individuals, including the handicapped, and is applied equally." Recent court decisions, as presented in Cavallaro v. Ambach, 575 Fed. Supp. 171 and Mahan v. Agee, 652 p.2d 765, have supported the age eligibility rule and considered it reasonable and fair.
babedan
August 9, 2011 2:34 p.m.
• Report abuse

Why does the state law say that 19 is too old? According to the Wake County Public School System website: "Nearly all parents choose to enroll their 5-year-olds in kindergarten even though the state does not require children to be enrolled in school until the age of 7." If the state doesn't require children to be enrolled until they are 7 years old, then there may be plenty of high schoolers who are 19 or 20 years old, who were just following state laws about when they had to enroll in school. This law should be changed immediately to accommodate all students who fall into this category and want to play sports through their senior year. While it may be less common, having a senior in high school who is 19 or 20 does not mean they were held back or failed to pass any grade level. Why purposely exclude any students despite the fact that they followed the enrollment law?
beulahk1
August 9, 2011 2:14 p.m.
• Report abuse

This is a prime example of what's wrong with our country today. Parents want the rules and regulations adjusted to fit their child's desires or is it the parents desires?? I look at this issue not as a disability issue, but the "age" issue of a student who has happened to "age out" of suiting up for football based on the rules that have been set forth by the NCHAA. A rule or regulation is just that and we all need to abide by them and stop trying to find away around them. This student has many other ways in which he can be a part of the team and that should be explored and considered without having to adjust any rule. This issue could be a great "teachable" moment for all students, if parents would use it as such.
wmsb63
August 9, 2011 1:35 p.m.
• Report abuse

Oh well, right or wrong, good or bad... have a GREAT season Hobbton, hope all the players are studying hard, and best wishes to everyone involved!
cheezchicken
August 9, 2011 1:27 p.m.
• Report abuse

No choice in this one. It's a cut and dried rule. Like one writer mentioned he can still be with the team as a student manager, and he could stay involved with the team.
Hokie 94
August 9, 2011 1:19 p.m.
• Report abuse

Sorry folks, but at age 19 the rule is the rule. No exceptions. We all have rules we must live by and this young man must too. You have to explain that he can't do what he wants because he is too old, If mom can't handle this then mom needs a shot of reality.

Again, the solution is to make him an equipment manager. He can run on the field during time outs and give the team water, tend to their needs on the side line and given a since of responsibility. Now giving this young man responsibilities better than just saying here's a uniform now stand here and do nothing. As an equipment manager, he will still be able to cheer, give high fives but he will also have that responsibility of tending to the players and I will bet anyone of you he will get more enjoyment out of that then just standing around with a uniform on.
babedan
August 9, 2011 1:14 p.m.
• Report abuse

Caring, sharing, community, development, involvement, and a whole lot more. If an athletic association is allowed to dictate to a school what they may and may not do, then our system of education has gotten totally out of control. It's sad, but today, sports is more important than a well-rounded education. It just shows where our priorities lay. And NOT where they SHOULD. bigal02282

Well said!!
cheezchicken
August 9, 2011 12:51 p.m.
• Report abuse

@mego- With all heartfelt sympathy and due respect, having been through a suicide in my own family and as a taxpayer in this state, I feel I have every right to make a mention of this. NC and the South in general seems to be mired in a good-old-boy mindset where it's ok if the "governing body" approves. How many times do they bend the rules and it doesn't make headlines? My point is that since this is apparently a State public school, whose sports program is run by people who are paid with funds from the citizens of this state, it seems they could put their efforts in a place that is more effective. Let the kid stand on the sidelines in a uniform. Big deal. Keep the players safe both mentally and physically and remember that they are in high school to educate themselves in order to hopefully make this a better world.
cheezchicken
August 9, 2011 12:48 p.m.
• Report abuse

I feel bad that this young man cannot "suit up," but a rule is a rule. He is not being told he cannot suit up because of his disability, it is because of his age. If an exception is made for him, a lot of people will then try to play past their eligibility. From what I read, he is still allowed on the sidelines, and may still wear the jersey. His life is not being ruined by this, and maybe there are other solutions to help him continue to feel included. I say all of this having a brother with a disability very similar to Downs Syndrome. We never expected special allowances because of his disability. If he could not do something based on his age, then he could not do it.
burnnurse19812
August 9, 2011 12:26 p.m.
• Report abuse

page 1 | 2 | 3
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

This story is closed for comments.