Find My Team

Submit PhotosLog InRegister

High School Sports

Could Millbrook's 4-A status be in jeopardy as a magnet school?


Jan 22, 2009

RALEIGH — It's safe to say that many people at Millbrook High School in Raleigh aren't excited about becoming a magnet school.

Broughton High School was stripped of it's magnet status last year, and the Wake County Public School System announced that Millbrook would become a magnet school. In order to make room for the magnet students, however, several hundred students at Millbrook may be reassigned to a different school.

Some have voiced concerns that the school system won't be able to fill the large number of spots, and as a result, it could impact the school's classification status in the N.C. High School Athletic Association.

Currently, Millbrook is a 4-A school with and Average Daily Membership number of 2,386. The large number of students ranks Millbrook No. 10 in the state, and No. 4 in Wake County behind Wakefield (2,713), Enloe (2,623) and Leesville Road (2,480).

Like reassignment, the NCHSAA conducts a periodic realignment where they redo the classifications based on ADM numbers, and put schools into new conferences. Realignment occurs every four years in the NCHSAA, and the new realignment goes into place in August.

The new realignment lists Millbrook as a 4-A school in a conference with Broughton, Enloe, Leesville Road, Sanderson, Wakefield and Wake Forest-Rolesville.

Many people expressed concerns at a public hearing at Millbrook. Some of the concerns were about the impact on athletics, and the possibility that Millbrook could become the county's only school without a 4-A status. Those concerned believe losing several hundred students would drop Millbrook to the 3-A classification.

According to athletic officials, however, that will not happen.

"It has already been approved by the Board of Directors and there is always a domino effect," said Rick Strunk, the associate executive director of the NCHSAA. "You can't change just one school without effecting many others."

The realignment process takes into account every member school's ADM. They are adjusted by the NCHSAA to reflect academies and other special situations at specific schools. After that, the largest fourth of the schools are placed into the 4-A classification. The next largest fourth goes into 3-A, and the process continues until all schools are placed into either 4-A, 3-A, 2-A or 1-A classifications.

After the initial divisions are made, the Realignment Committee must put together a proposal for new conferences. The proposal is then discussed at regional meetings where schools and school systems can give their feedback.

Once the committee has finalized their proposal, the Board of Directors votes on the proposed realignment and it becomes final.

Changing one school means other schools have to be changed as well.

Wake County's senior director of athletics Bobby Guthrie agreed with Strunk that Millbrook would be a 4-A school next school year.

"I am not sure about the numbers for Millbrook, but Millbrook High School will be a 4-A school for the upcoming realignment," Guthrie said. "There may be some reduction of Millbrook at the beginning of the changeover to magnet status, but I expect that will be for a short period of time."

If a large number of magnet seats go unfilled, that would give Millbrook a severe disadvantage on the athletic playing field because they would have a smaller number of students to pull from to play sports.

If that is indeed a problem, there is something Millbrook can do.

"If a school has something that dramatically changes [it's ADM numbers] - usually it is opening a new school that takes students from an existing school but it could be like Millbrook - there is a chance to appeal at the midpoint of the four-year period," said Strunk. "So at the Board meeting in late November [or] early December of 2010 those could be presented. So Millbrook's change in status, if it does occur as you indicate, could happen then. It might drop."

Still, it is only a possibility that Millbrook's status could change from 4-A to 3-A, and the earliest that would happen would be the 2011-2012 school year.

Should Millbrook be dropped to the 3-A class, it is unclear what conference they would become a part of. Speculation provides two potential conferences, defined as "Conference 6" and "Conference 7" in the 2009-2010 realignment plan.

Conference 6 includes Cardinal Gibbons, Northern Vance, Southern Vance, Chapel Hill, Orange and J.F. Webb. Conference 7 is made up of Southern Lee, Western Harnett, Overhills, Union Pines, Douglas Byrd, Gray's Creek and Westover.

"There is lots of opportunity during the process itself to anticipate some of these changes, especially with new schools, but at this point the realignment has been set and the next avenue will be the appeal to the Board in 2010," said Strunk.

Another change could be on the horizon

In an interview with HighSchoolOT.com last August, the executive director of the NCHSAA, Charlie Adams, said that he believes the days of four classifications are over in North Carolina.

Adams told HighSchoolOT.com that he expects a 5-A class to be added in the next realignment, which will take place in time for the 2013-2014 school year. This is likely to divide Wake County high schools among the 5-A class and 4-A class.

The addition of a 5-A class would have to be approved by the Board of Directors prior to the realignment process beginning.

COMMENTS

11 Comments



page 1 | 2
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Just another reason why the NCHSAA should realign every two years instead of four.
RD28327
January 23, 2009 8:00 p.m.
• Report abuse

Good gosh. You two are getting too far into specifics, lol! I think the more information we can get, the better. By reporting what the procedures are, us in the "general public" (for lack of a better term) and outside the NCHSAA/WCPSS circle, we don't know what the process is. I didn't have a clue how realignment worked, and I figured the WCPSS had authority over the NCHSAA.

Anyway... Nick, I hate to see you're turning down a spot in politics. You'd be a good one!
Football is Awesome
January 23, 2009 5:47 p.m.
• Report abuse

I stand corrected, Nick. "Accurate" was a poor choice of words and it wasn't what I meant, so I didn't recall writing it like that. "Applicable" is maybe a better word, or "accurate" in the context that it will not happen? Semantics, I know, and my apologies.

You wrote: "I believe it is my responsibility to report that it is not true." Then you wrote: "I don't think it is a bad thing to report what would happen should Millbrook be dropped to 3-A."

Well, which is it?

If your goal was to dispel the rumor, then outlining appeal processes and possible 3A conferences doesn't seem (to me, anyway) the best way to go about it. You could have just stopped with Strunk and Guthrie confirming MB will be 4A next year because the realignment is already in place. Or you could have found the numbers showing MB's base is well over 4A without a single magnet kid.

IMHO, citing possible conferences and appeal processes makes it sound like it still COULD happen, when there is no way it will.
Marvin
January 23, 2009 2:54 p.m.
• Report abuse

"...meaning there is not a single accurate thing in your article..."

Sorry, I took that to mean there was something inaccurate in the article.

We'll just have to agree to disagree about it being a non-story. I happen to think that when rumors are spreading about a drastic change like that, it is a story.

As far as the potential 3-A conference, that stems from Rick Strunk's explanation of how it would happen should Millbrook need to drop to 3-A in two years. If they did, those are the two most likely possibilities - Conference 6 & 7. I don't think it is a bad thing to report what would happen should Millbrook be dropped to 3-A.

But like I said, we can agree to disagree.

Bottom line is, if we didn't have these drastic changes in reassignment year in and year out we wouldn't have to write these articles at all. Magnet schools could be placed in the "poorer" schools to help balance them out, and they wouldn't have to move.
Nick Stevens
January 23, 2009 2:14 p.m.
• Report abuse

Sorry - "I don't know who" should not be in the previous post.
Marvin
January 23, 2009 1:49 p.m.
• Report abuse

As I said Nick, I'm normally a big fan but I think you blew it here. And by the way, I never said it was inaccurate - I said it was poor reporting.

Your article is titled "Could Millbrook's 4-A status be in jeopardy as a magnet school?" The answer is an unequivocal no. The WCPSS plans to leave a base of 1613 students, which is well inside 4-A range without a single magnet student. (http://blogs.newsobserver.com/wakeed/emptying-millbrook-high) If your purpose was to discount the rumor that Millbrook could somehow go 3-A, then all you needed to do was say that Millbrook's base without any magnet students would be well above 4A level.

Instead, you quote Rick Strunk and Bobby Guthrie and write a couple of hundred words including possible 3A conferences for a scenario that you say cannot happen. It is a non-story and anyone who knows about WCPSS or how the NCHSAA works knows that. I am surprised you blew it out to that proportion. That's my only complaint.

I don't know who
Marvin
January 23, 2009 1:48 p.m.
• Report abuse

Marvin, these were rumors and issues that were raised by people who were concerned about the change at Millbrook. Therefore, I believe it is my responsibility to report that it is not true.

I'm not sure what in the article is not accurate. I can tell you that everything in the article is accurate. Maybe you have your facts wrong?
Nick Stevens
January 23, 2009 11:15 a.m.
• Report abuse

Nick, this is an absolutely ridiculous article and I am surprised because normally you do such a great job.

Broughton, as a magnet school, has nearly 2000 students and no problems competing in 4A.

The cut-off for 4A at the last realignment was somewhere around 1400. That means Millbrook would have to lose nearly half their student body for that to even be a possibility, and that's not going to happen.

In addition, the realignment for 2009-2013 is already set. Schools could appeal to be reclassified at the two-year point if they had a significant enrollment change, but otherwise the alignment is set for four years. Therefore the earliest anything could happen is 2013, when by your article Charlie Adams says we'll be looking at a 5A, meaning there is not a single accurate thing in your article other than Millbrook and Broughton swapping magnet status.

Sorry it was such a slow week with the snow that you had to dredge up this garbage. Poor reporting.
Marvin
January 23, 2009 8:56 a.m.
• Report abuse

Yeah, I'm not sure what 24-0 means.

Anyway, FIA, I don't see a future for me on the school board, haha... But I'm glad someone agrees with me!
Nick Stevens
January 22, 2009 10:42 p.m.
• Report abuse

Want to clarify that jsw?

Thanks for proving that rumor wrong, Nick. However, making Millbrook a magnet school is bad all the way around. Of course, I know I'm preaching to the choir, because I know you disagree with the reassignment process, Nick. How many years until you can run for school board?
Football is Awesome
January 22, 2009 7:09 p.m.
• Report abuse

page 1 | 2
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

This story is closed for comments.